Survivor Quits Pope's Panel On Sex Abuse, Citing 'Shameful' Resistance

A key member of the sex-abuse commission established by Pope Francis has resigned, citing her frustration with the resistance the panel has encountered at the Vatican.

Ms Collins, who was raped at age 13 by a hospital chaplain in Ireland, was the only active abuse survivor on the commission after British abuse survivor, Peter Saunders, was stood aside by the Vatican panel previous year for his outspoken criticism, even though he has not resigned or been formally dismissed.

"It is a reflection of how this whole abuse crisis in the church has been handled: with fine words in public and contrary actions behind closed doors", she said.

Collins, the only member of the panel who abstained from the vote to suspend Saunders, wrote at the time that it was unclear to some whether Saunders could work constructively and confidentially within the confines of the commission's mission.

Collins charged that a lack of cooperation on the part of other Vatican offices has stalled the Commission, preventing the implementation of policies meant to protect children and hold clergy accountable for committing or covering up abuse. Recently, she says, there was "a specific refusal from a department of the Vatican that I felt was just unacceptable".

When Cardinal Sean O'Malley of Boston and his team at the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors recommended that the pope name Collins and Saunders as members, the intentions were obviously noble.

Krysten Winter-Green, a member of the commission and a social worker who helps abuse survivors, said many prelates within the Vatican strongly support the commission's work, but "there is a tremendous degree of frustration" involved with working within the Vatican bureaucracy.

She said the "last straw" that led to her handing in her letter of resignation was when she learned that the same dicastery that refused to cooperate on the safeguarding guidelines had also refused "to implement one of the simplest recommendations the commission has put forward to date".

Ms Collins became a household name nearly two decades ago when she challenged the late Cardinal Desmond Connell's failure to report to the gardaĆ­ her abuse in childhood by a priest of his diocese.




Ms Collins said "a simple recommendation approved by Pope Francis" late a year ago on a small procedural change to the care of sex abuse victims was refused.

She described the blocking of "a simple recommendation approved by Pope Francis" by Vatican officials late previous year as "the last straw" that led her to resign.

Collins, an Irish woman who suffered abuse by a priest during a hospital stay as a child, is a widely respected and blunt-spoken voice in the survivor community.

Certainly, the bureaucratic inertia and power games described by Collins raise legitimate questions about how serious the Vatican may be in terms of its commitment to reform.

Collins says she is leaving the panel because, as she told The Telegraph, "there are people in the Vatican who do not want to change or understand the need to change".

In a press release, the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors praised Collins' "consistent" and "tireless" work on behalf of survivors of sexual abuse by priests.

In the past, Francis has met with abuse victims and begged forgiveness for the church.

The commission will be meeting in Rome March 20-26, and it is expected members will discuss what to do next about participation by other survivors since its mission includes reaching out to and including victims, a source told Catholic News Service. He said she will continue to work with the Commission on training programmes for new bishops and for other offices of the Holy See.

(Copyright © 2015. All Rights Reserved.)
 
Recommended

Doctors issue new warning about marijuana
In the USA , many parents believe that pot use is harmless and it could not affect their children. The adverse effects of marijuana have been well documented.

Amal Clooney's baby bump upstages George
The sighting marks the couple's first red carpet appearance since news broke earlier this month of their pregnancy. Amal , who never disappoints with her style, stepped out with George in a back and white ensemble on Saturday.

GOP congressman says no room for compromise in repealing Obamacare
Trump told reporters earlier this month that the White House will release its health care plan by "maybe mid to early March". As the same time, many millions of people have gotten health insurance because of the federal government's program.

Transgender wrestler's state bid spotlights Texas policy
Beggs is transitioning from female to male and wants to wrestle boys according to his grandmother, but UIL rules won't let him. In the lawsuit against the UIL , it claims allowing Beggs to compete puts other girls at an "imminent threat of bodily harm".

Lewis Hamilton: Mercedes's new auto given debut at Silverstone
Firstly, very proud to continue with this team. "It has been a long, hard slog for him and he finally got the title". I believe in myself, I believe it is possible - but like I say I do need to go step by step, race by race.

Katy Perry & Orlando Bloom Split, Taking a 'Loving' Break
Moreover, sources revealed that Erin swapped her place card just to sit near the actor. Engagement rumors were constantly part of Katy and Orlando's year of romance.

Post-demonetisation slow down in GDP
Similarly, growth in the mining sector is projected to slowdown to 1.3 per cent from 12.3 per cent in 2015-16. Personal consumption expenditures: Increased by 1.9%, down slightly from last estimate's 2%.

Perth Adele impersonator joins her idol for onstage selfie and singalong
The Grammy and Oscar victor could add stand-up comedian to her talents, as she delighted the crowd with several amusing anecdotes. Singer Adele was left starstruck when she pulled a drag queen impersonator onstage with her and handed over the microphone.

"Alien" Introduces Its First Gay Couple In New Scene From "Alien: Covenant"
Ridley Scott is probably going to include more than a few nods to the original Aliens franchise in his upcoming Alien: Covenant . His wife is played by Upstream Color star Amy Seimetz, which is an actor combination I never thought we'd ever see.

Try crepes with a twist this Pancake Tuesday
Britons are looking forward to making and devouring pancakes with family and friends to celebrate Pancake Day today. Heat a small frying pan and grease with butter then ladle in enough batter to coat the base of the pan.

David Moyes relishing his Everton return with Sunderland
I wanted them to take the ball a bit more and be braver in the second half and I thought we did that. Romelu Lukaku in particular seems to be on a hot streak, scoring 9 goals in his last 10 games.

Warren Buffett criticises Wall Street as Apple investment pays off
At December 31, 2016, Berkshire's book value had increased by 10.7% since year end 2015 to $172,108 per Class A equivalent share. Analysts on average had forecast operating profit of $2,716.60 per share, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.

Panel urges caution as NASA studies flying crew on first SLS
The SLS rocket is now scheduled to make its debut flight, Exploration Mission 1 (EM-1), in sometime in late 2018 or early 2019. The main priority, he said, would be to ensure it can be done while limiting the potential risks to the crew's safety.

Jefferies Group Weighs in on Domino's Pizza Inc's FY2018 Earnings (DPZ)
Analysts await Domino's Pizza Inc (NASDAQ: DPZ ) to report earnings on Feb, 28 for the fiscal quarter ending Dec 2016. Oasis Management Co Ltd. acquired a new stake in shares of Domino's Pizza during the second quarter worth $5,190,000.

Ukip donor Banks will stand against party's only MP
UKIP's only MP has discussed re-defecting back the Conservatives at the next election with senior Tories, the Sun can reveal. Ukip is in an increasing state of turmoil after failing to win the Stoke Central by-election last Thursday.


More News

News
More News